Evaluating the Business Performance through Financial Statement Indicators: A Systematic Review of Published Dissertations

 

Kushal De1, Sandip Bhattacharyya2*

1Assistant Professor, Dhruba Chand Halder College, Dakshin Barasat,

South 24 Parganas, West Bengal – 743372, India.

2Research Scholar, Department of Commerce, University of Calcutta, 87/1 College Street,

Kolkata – 700073, India.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: dekushal@yahoo.in, sandip2074@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

Analysis of Financial performance that can evaluates the financial health of companies. The study presents a systematic literature review to assess past research focused on the use of solvency, liquidity and profitability indicators for financial analysis. In this paper, it has been analysed how macroeconomic factors affect solvency. It has also been observed that interest rates and inflation influence debt levels and capital structure across industries. The findings show that traditional liquidity ratios lack of debt. In the other hand cash flow analysis offers better insights. There is limited use of ESG in profitability analysis, though firms with good governance show better earnings and firms with sustainable practices often perform better in the long run. The dominance of Altman Z score is also observed with limited focus on distress indicators. The study will help stakeholders make better decisions and promote more sustainable financial practices in a growing economy.

 

KEYWORDS: Financial performance, Solvency, Liquidity, ESG, Profitability, Sustainability.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

Financial performance has long been a central theme in corporate finance. It can be offering critical insights into health and variability of business enterprises1. India’s capital markets are volatile. As a result, financial aspects like solvency, liquidity, profitability and financial distress are also becoming more complex and dynamic2. A number of doctoral dissertations in India had sought to examine the above-mentioned aspects across various sectors, employing a range of analytical models and empirical techniques3.

 

A well-structured comprehensive review of existing studies is still lacking. The heterogeneity of the corporate environment in sectors like Information Technology, Pharma, Cement, Automobile, Rubber, Refineries, Heavy Industries etc. add layers of complexity to financial performance analysis. In this context evaluating a firm's performance requires an integrated view that emphasizes not only on financial ratios but also on qualitative aspects like ethical practices, governance quality, sustainable auditing practices4. Understanding the corporate reporting trend over changing operational periods helps to frame how these financial indicators shift dynamically5. A systematic literature review of fifty completed doctoral dissertations from several universities offers an opportunity to map research trends, evaluate and identify the research gaps for future study. The present study through systematic literature review classifies the research into key thematic categories like capital structure and solvency analysis, liquidity and operational efficiency, profitability and earnings quality, financial distress prediction and comparative analysis across industrial sectors. The study also explores the extent to which other studies incorporate qualitative models, stakeholder perspective and sectoral comparisons.

 

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY:

The key objective of this study is to investigate doctoral dissertations, available on Shodhganga reservoir portal and focus on the financial performance, by evaluating the companies operating in the Indian economy.

·       The study aims to organize the reviewed literature into five broad thematic sub-headings namely capital structure and solvency analysis, liquidity and operational efficiency, profitability and earnings quality, financial distress prediction and comparative analysis across industrial sectors. These thematic domains have been identified based on different patterns and points that have been observed across the selected body of research.

·       To explore the conceptual framework and operational approaches adopted by researchers in evaluating various aspects of financial performance.

·       To identify common trends, key findings and significant divergence within the existing body of literature.

 

RESEARCH GAP:

Many existing doctoral dissertations have examined the financial performance of various Indian industries and a trend is observed. The dissertations have often focused on individual financial aspects like solvency, profitability, liquidity and distress prediction. There has been limited comparative research that discovers these variations. This restricts applicability of the findings in a broader context. Limited research has examined how the theme has evolved over time. The gap becomes vibrant while looking at the changes in India’s regulatory environment. Major economic reforms have also played a role but remain underexamined. The present study seeks to address these probable gaps by compiling and critically assessing the findings of fifty doctoral dissertations. It also aims to offer an integrated perspective of financial performance research by highlighting different areas of study.

 

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY:

This study demonstrates the substantial significance as it systematically amalgamates several decades of doctoral dissertations from various universities of India that focus on corporate financial performance. While many doctoral dissertations have detonated critical financial variables like Solvency, Profitability, Liquidity, and Financial Distress. There is a lack of consolidated analysis to map sectoral trends. The study helps fulfil this gap by organizing fifty doctoral studies based on different themes and methods. It creates the knowledge base for future researchers, policy makers and audit professionals. From an academic point of view, it shows key research trends to study financial performance. On a practical level, it helps representatives, managers and company leaders to understand how financial performance matches or differs from real conditions in Indian Industries. It also encourages the need for enhanced corporate transparency so that sector-specific financial strategies can be devised to add a more robust framework for early financial distress prediction.

 

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:

This study has adopted a systematic literature review to evaluate fifty doctoral dissertations related to financial performance across various Indian firms. The dissertations were selected based on their relevance to key financial performance areas. These include solvency, profitability and financial distress prediction. Each dissertation was closely studied to extract essential data and thematic content including the objective of study, theoretical framework, data collection techniques and analytical methods employed.

 

Data Source:

This study collected fifty doctoral dissertations from the Shodhganga Reservoir Portal which, an archive of published dissertations database.

 

Period of Study:

The selected dissertations were published between 2010 and 2024.

 

Selection Criteria:

Only dissertations related to financial performance which focused on Solvency, Profitability, Comparative Sectoral Performance Analysis and Financial Distress Prediction were included.

 

Thematic sub-heading categorisation:

Based on the content, the dissertations were organized into five thematic groups namely, Capital Structure and Solvency Analysis, Liquidity Assessment and Operational Efficiency, Profitability Metrics and Earnings Quality, Financial Distress and Prediction model, and Comparative Analysis across industry sectors.

 

RESEARCH QUESTIONS:

The study has identified several unexplored areas across five thematic domains. To address the gaps identified in available literature, the following research questions have been formulated.

 

RESEARCH QUESTION 1: (CAPITAL STRUCTURE AND SOLVENCY ANALYSIS):

In spite of extensive use of financial ratios and different statistical models, limited focus has been given to dynamic solvency determinants and contextual factors. The question which needs to be explored is: How do macroeconomic variables like interest rate and inflation rate influence long term solvency (with respect to capital structure decisions across different industry sectors)? What is the impact of strategic debt restructuring on long term solvency in mid cap and large cap firms?

 

Most of the reviewed literature examined how Indian companies manage debt and equity financing and their impact on financial stability. The traditional financial ratios such as debt equity ratio and interest coverage ratio along with regression analysis are used to explore the determinants of capital structure. There are few studies which incorporate dynamic models or consider macroeconomic factors affecting solvency.6 showed that most of the dairy firms have comprehensive financial analysis with some variability. Non-recurring challenges in terms of solvency factor, that is, debt equity ratio show a minor variability but generally reflect controlled debt levels. The equity ratio shows different ownership strengths. profitability, net profit margin, return on asset and return on capital employed vary across diary firms. In terms of efficiency, asset turnover ratio reflects differences in operational efficiency among various dairy firms. Different statistical tests like ANOVA identify significant performance disparities and support the need for strategic measures.7 analyzed the financial performance of six major pharmaceutical companies. The study observed that Sun Pharma and Lupin pharmaceutical companies demonstrate strong operational efficiency and leverage management, contrary to Cipla and Aurobindo Pharmaceutical Company that show signs of financial distress with least liquidity and profitability.

 

In the sectoral context the pharmaceutical space highlights how the capital structures face the specific stresses during the strategic shift that is corporate restructuring.8 evaluated the dynamic changes in financial leverage has been driven by merger and acquisitions within a pharmaceutical industry finding that regional operational financial variances across geographical zones such as Delhi NCRs heavily dictated post-merger solvency level.9 examined the determinants of financial leverage across fifteen key industries in India. The result showed that solvency and profitability strongly influenced financial leverage, depending upon the variable's direction and strength. Four Industries exhibit a significant relationship between cost of capital and financial leverage.10 showed that an automobile company namely Hero Honda, used an optimal debt equity ratio by focusing on internal resources and fund management. It also included reserve and surplus, reflecting strong profitability and earnings per share for equity shareholders. Hero Honda also exhibits high return on capital employed, while other automobile companies like Bajaj Auto excel in Net Asset Turnover Ratio after their demerger effect.11 identified significant variability in National Housing Development Corporation’s capital structure and asset base. Secured loan and reserve consistently augment which indicates reliance on internal accruals and long-term borrowings from funding growth. The researcher investigates profitability and capital structure of the companies to determine their fund flow position.12 examined the overall efficiency of financial management within selected firms. The research found that NRB bearings limited maintained a conservative but financially sound capital structure, with internal equity dominating long term debt. Profitability metrics showed marginal fluctuations over different financial years. The company’s operational efficiency improved by utilising fixed assets beyond working capital.13 examined the impact of capital structure and found that the debt equity ratio significantly affected net profit margin but had only a marginal influence on return on equity and return on asset. No significant effect is found on net profit margin, but an impact on return on capital employed, return on asset and return on equity is observed.

 

To expand these financial insights outside private sectors, normal nature of standard evaluations is crucial.14 established foundational baseline criteria for financial metrics by building a strutted normative model aimed at standardizing performance across diverse commercial undertakings in the volatile macroeconomic environments.

 

FINDINGS:

The reviewed studies reveal that financial performance and solvency vary widely among sectors and are influenced by internal and external factors. Many firms maintain stable debt levels and optimize their debt equity ratios while depending on an internal source of funds, that is, reserve and surplus to support their profitability and efficiency. Solvency and profitability strongly affect financial leverage, indicating that capital structure decisions are shaped by industry specific conditions and economic environment. While traditional financial ratios provide an insight, the varying impact of these factors across different industries suggest that macroeconomic conditions like interest rates changes and inflation are likely to affect a firm’s long-term solvency in a different way.7 analyzed the financial performance of six major pharmaceutical companies through comprehensive assessment of working capital management in respect to solvency and operational efficiency.

 

RESEARCH QUESTION 2: (LIQUIDITY AND OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY):

Most of the studies rely upon basic computation of financial ratios without incorporating sectoral stress-testing mechanisms. The question which needs to be explored is: Does Cash Flow Analysis improve liquidity forecasting and operational efficiency in India’s MNC’s?

 

There are several studies focusing on liquidity management and its role in operational performance, particularly in manufacturing and service sectors. Ratio analysis like current ratio and quick ratio, supplemented by several statistical tests to investigate the cash flow management and operational efficiency. There are sectoral differences in liquidity management practices that are underexplored.15 examined Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). This study showed more comprehensive assessment of operational and financial efficiency. Data Envelopment Analysis evaluates relative efficiency considering multiple input factors and resulting output concurrently. The findings showed that Hero Motocrop, a leading automobile company demonstrated the stable efficiency among its peer groups.16 assessed the financial performance of the Indian paper and paint industry by analyzing liquidity, profitability and efficiency ratios. The stock turnover ratio and daily sales in inventory varied across firms. In comparison, Nerolac displayed high inventory efficiency, while Shalimar paints showed lower levels of efficiency. Highest current liabilities and rapid growth in debt capital in Shalimar, reflect differing working capital strategies. To find out how working capital and cash structure functions vertically down to baseline localised corporate operations, insight of macro regional trend may be evaluated.17 established foundational evidence on corporate working capital behaviour by focusing on structural liquidity analysis within the cluster components of corporate sectors in Eastern India.18 investigated how the decision of Asset Liability Management (ALM) impacted the financial position, liquidity risk and overall performance of selected housing finance companies in India. Some housing finance companies like Repco homes and India-Bulls show optimal capital utilization and Investor Returns, while DHFL faced significant financial distress leading to insolvency. Liquidity risk varied significantly as LIC housing finance showed low risk and HUDCO showed high risk.19 examined the role and financial performance of NGOs operating in the Konkan region in India. Secondary Data Analysis shows that nearly 20% of NGOs in that Konkan region ensure a stable survival ratio, including short term solvency concerns. Doner’s dependency is highest among religious NGOs, while income utilization ratios were satisfactory across the categories. From the primary data survey, a statistically significant relationship is seen between NGOs and the quality of service delivered.20 examined the financial performance and operational efficiency of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL). The author evaluated the management efficiency based on secondary data. Liquidity indicators such as current ratio, quick ratio and cash flow operating ratio constantly declined below the industrial standard, which indicate poor financial health and negative working conditions. Asset utilization and working capital management are inefficient and ANOVA tests confirm a statistically significant variation in liquidity and profitability with respect to solvency over time.

 

Service-based information structures present divergent liquidity dynamics compared to heavy manufacturing industries.21 evaluated short-term financial safety situations and asset utilisations rates across the corporate entities in the information technology sector that is identifying how cash conversions save the companies from the financial volatility.

 

FINDINGS:

The reviewed studies suggest that traditional liquidity ratios such as current and quick ratios offer basic financial insights but they fall short while reflecting real time liquidity stress or operational efficiency, especially across various sectors. In manufacturing and service sectors, findings show that firms with declining cash flow indicators often face poor working capital management, inefficient asset utilization, and substandard liquidity position. On the other hand, organizations that maintain strong liquidity through internal cash management strategies demonstrate higher operational flexibility. This is apparent in sectors like housing finance and telecom, where companies with structured liquidity planning performed better despite financial pressure. Significant variations in liquidity management strategies across firms suggest the importance of contextual cash flow pursuing in various sectors.

 

RESEARCH QUESTION 3: (PROFITABILITY AND EARNINGS QUALITY):

What is the long-term effect of Environmental, Social, Governance (ESG) ESG adoption on profitability and earnings quality among listed public firms or other corporate sectors?

 

Profitability is evaluated by using of return on asset, return on equity, and earnings per share to assess financial success. Several studies also assess earning quality through accounting and accrual conservatism metrics.22 evaluated the financial performance of non-banking financial corporations (NBFCs) in India in the time frame of 2010 to 2020. Manappuram Finance Limited emerged as the top performer in terms of overall financial health that demonstrated strong profitability and efficiency. Conversely another NBFC, namely SREI Infrastructure Limited, showed high solvency but lesser profitability and efficiency. The financial ratios across NBFCs showed no significant differences, indicating comparable debt equity structures, leverages, profitability and asset management.23 evaluated the profitability of thirty two Indian cement companies during the post-liberalization era (from 1991 to 2000). In the context of profitability, new firms outperformed, while larger firms consistently maintained their profits above the industrial average. Smaller firms have demonstrated enhanced profitability and steady growth trends over recent financial years, suggesting better performance in the sector.24 evaluated significant differences in Profitability, Liquidity, Efficiency and Solvency among twelve Indian companies over a period of ten financial years. One of the leading industries namely Page Industries consistently ranked the highest in return-based metrics, while another leading industry Gakalads Exports showed the weakest performance across several financial ratios. Kitex Garments excelled in gross profit and inventory turnover ratios. This has also been confirmed by Single Factor ANOVA across all financial parameters.25 adapted an analytical qualitative research approach to explore the impact of accounting disclosures on the quality of financial and non-financial performance in the context of financial reporting. Relating to primary data, it confirmed non-financial disclosures enhance transparency, stakeholder’s trust, assessing intangible assets and social responsibility. This study found that banks and financial institutions rely on relevant financial disclosure policies.26 exhibited a significant rise in domestic mergers in India in the post-liberalization era with an active participation from finance industries and other relevant industries like Information Technology, Pharmaceuticals and Chemicals. However, the merger did not bring a notable change in liquidity and solvency position of an acquiring company. Decline in profitability was observed particularly among small cap firms. The long-term analysis over the past five financial years showed that the merger contributed to shareholder’s wealth creation primarily in large cap acquisitions.27 evaluated financial performance in respect to leading Indian Aluminum firms using profitability matrices such as Return on Asset, Return on Equity, Return on Net worth etc. One of the leading companies, namely Century Limited, posted the highest average return on net worth but showed negative growth, while Sacheta Metals demonstrated consistent growth across return on net worth and Return on Capital Employed. Multiple Regression and Correlation analysis were used to identify the critical factors influencing profitability across companies.

 

Profitability metrics are similarly driven by operational dynamics especially to heavy consumer resource segments such as automotive components or specialized manufacturing fields.28 investigated structural income generation and return metrics within the rubber manufacturing sector to drawing out how fluctuations in raw material input cost influence profitability trends across corporate entities.

Analyzing energy distribution performance states that how the major state-supported infrastructure systems reserve earning stability.29 evaluated institutional financial performance and capital disposition returns of National Thermal Power Corporations (NTPC) representing the impact of high long-term investment scales on sustainable public sector corporate entities.

 

FINDINGS:

The reviewed studies emphasize profitability through key metrics such as return on asset, return on equity and earnings per share addressing the consistency and reliability of earnings over time. However, most research studies focused on financial indicators without fully incorporating Environmental, Social and Governance dimensions.

 

RESEARCH QUESTION 4: (FINANCIAL DISTRESS PREDICTION MODEL):

Traditional models like Altman Z Score are widely used with limited exploration of SMEs, qualitative factors or different financial modeling. The question which needs to be explored is: How effectively do qualitative indicators like Audit Report and Management Turnover during buy-in or buy-out predict financial distress in high-risk firms?

 

This thematic sub-heading focuses on the studies that aim to predict corporate failure or financial distress using various statistical models. Altman Z score distress prediction models tend to focus on large farms with lowered attention on SMEs or the sector specific risk factors.30 demonstrated the cause of financial distress in selected companies based on their disclosures and annual reports by verifying various national and international models. The author applied different financial ratios across several firms from different industries like metal, sugar, paper and textile over a few financial years before distress event factors.31 analysed the financial performance and bankruptcy risk of select Indian Insurance companies by using Altman Z scre model. The author examined the regulatory environment, industry challenges and key financial decisions through qualitative methods based on financial statements. Under her study, she revealed that correlation analysis showed that Altman Z score was strongly influenced by return on asset, liquidity and profitability metrics. In contrast asset turnover ratio and return on equity did not show significant correlations.32 assessed the condition of distress firms after the resolution process began in 2017. The author studied the role of financial awareness and analysed the key stages of financial recovery. The study identified the key factors having financial stability. Decline in working capital emerges as the most critical factor, which influences liquidity and solvency. The findings of present data total asset and liability of the firm. The analysis indicated debt levels have a significant influence on financial health and long-term survival of the business.33 identified financial risk and uncertainty in many firms due to insufficient amount of liquidity and earnings, and heavy financial debt. The study included both company level and industry level analysis to assess improvement and growth. Industries such as pharmaceuticals and cement showed mild to moderate signs to financial distress. This was mainly due to high interest obligations and these sectors rarely reported financially sound earnings.

 

Financial distress model is forecasting beyond simple structural financial ratios, advanced accounting fraud screening models and specific sector financial stress.34 integrated machine learning applications and automated accounting networks to build financial misstatement and fraudulent indicators detection across industrial cross-sectional financial statements.35 investigated structural revenue of cash inflows, operating expenses, financial operational performance safety boundaries privileged the financial systems of Indian railways networks.36 examined asset health variations over longed historical timelines offers perceptions into structural stability. An institutional viability review and long-term distress model analysis across Indian commercial banking operations.37 investigated the capital structure and its impact on firm value. Most of the Indian firms adjusted their financial leverage towards a target capital structure, with an average adjustment rate of 25% in terms of resource utilization. Firms experiencing financial distress and those with high levels of promoter ownership tended to rely on more debt capital. A non-linear relationship exists among promoter ownership and financial leverage.38 revealed small medium enterprises across various districts in Chennai region, with a focus on socio economic and business profiles. The study identified the challenges faced in the financial planning, capital allocation, inventory control and working capital management. Working capital constraints have been driven by the delay in payments, inadequate inventory control and informal accounting practices.

 

FINDINGS:

The reviewed studies suggest that qualitative indicators can offer valuable insights when combined with financial matrices. Similarly, frequent changes in top management particularly during mergers, buy-in or buy-out give signals of operational disruptions or governance issues that lead to financial distress. In small medium enterprises, informal accounting practices and cash flow issues reduce the effectiveness of traditional models. Integrating qualitative indicators such as governance stability, audit report and management consistency into the existing models can enhance early detection of distress.

 

 

RESEARCH QUESTION 5: (COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS ACROSS INDUSTRIAL SECTORS):

Cross-sector comparisons are typically static and lack integration on issues of sustainability and governance dimensions. The question which needs to be explored is: How do sector-specific sustainability practices influence financial performance in different companies over time?

 

Traditional manufacturing sectors lag behind in different practices such as transparency, ethical governance, integration and sustainability reporting which correlate for better financial results. Comparative research has been supported by cross-sectional data and financial ratios lagging interrelated frameworks.39 explored that some companies faced prolonged financial difficulties. The companies examined the relationship between financial leverage and agency cost. By using Altman Z score Model, the author assessed how the financial variables such as profitability and growth influences financial health of companies.40 employed CAMEL’s framework to evaluate the financial performance of select banks for five financial years. The study results highlighted that private sector banks generally outperformed public-sector banks. Meanwhile public sector banks showed weakness in most of the CAMEL’s parameters. Private banks showed the stronger metrics in the Capital Adequacy Ratio, Debt Equity Ratio and Government Security holdings, while public sector banks reported higher Non-Performing Assets to Total Advances. Public sector banks exhibited high liquidity assets as reflected by their deposit to total asset ratio.

 

To broaden institutional banking compassion’s tracking financial trends across structural ages helps determine system stability.41 executed comprehensive multi-bank financial statements comparison using structural variables to determine core operational and investment soundness across diverse Indian banking groups.42 aimed to evaluate the corporate financial performance of select companies. The goal was to provide an insight to take decision making aptitude for shareholders and support sustainable growth. Under this study, the author revealed most of the dairy firms demonstrated improved liquidity ratios over a period of time with some variability indicating non-recurring challenges. In terms of solvency factors debt-equity ratio showed a minor variability but generally reflected controlled debt levels. Equity ratio indicated various ownership strengths. Statistical test ANOVA confirmed the significant differences in terms of financial performance in respect to solvency and liquidity, among the various dairy firms.43 investigated perpetual differences with respect to Indian Pharmaceutical Industries. The key financial metrics using cost structure, profitability and return on capital employed were examined such as product patents, price control, research and development expenditures. In this study, the author highlighted the audit expectation gap in India. This study revealed that auditors and financial statement users used to differ in the understanding of audit objectives, responsibilities and product outcomes in terms of financial variability.

 

Cross-sectional pharma metrics, individual firm’s analysis are essential.44 analysed micro level internal accounting financial statements and financial reporting disclosures of Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited to find out real world sectoral operational trends.45 analyzed the working capital components of three major leading paint companies in India. The analysis included average growth rates, inventory turnover ratios and daily sales in inventory to assess the operational efficiency. The study identified a significant variation in working capital management strategies and performance approaches among the firms.46 completed an independent industry appraisal tracing operational capital variables across competitive corporate paint manufacturers over a multi-year period, which has been supplemented by the evaluations mapping paint market variations.

 

Evaluating core resource extraction sectors provides a structure for state-backed heavy industry analysis.47 conducted an extensive corporate financial performance evaluation focusing on the operational line items of Eastern Coal Fields Limited.48 completed an industry wide financial review of leading life insurance companies, tracking financial performance indicators over the post reform period. Safety margins inside comparative fields like Insurance tracked across financial reform periods.49 analyzed corporate reporting statement to evaluate how specific indicator disclosures directly guide long-term asset investments and equity capital placement decisions.50 found that Indian companies generally comply with the basic ethical norms such as corporate social responsibility and spending patterns, but deeper ethical practices remain on a narrow side. Corporate Social Responsibility disclosures and Sustainability Reporting are inconsistent in the majority of the companies following a comprehensive framework of global reporting initiative.

 

FINDINGS:

The reviewed studies confirm that financial performance differs significantly across industrial sectors. In some areas traditional manufacturing and industrial sectors demonstrate financial stability Private sector banks outperform their public sector counterparts in areas of capital adequacy and efficiency. Most of the research studies suggest that companies investigating long term sustainability efforts, including environmental stewardship and governance improvements build stronger reputations and attract investor confidence, which lead to improved financial performance over time.

 

 

CONCLUSION:

Most doctoral dissertations depend on traditional financial ratios and basic statistical models. Research should emphasize various dynamic models and stakeholders’ inclusive frameworks to capture the complexities of financial health of Indian companies. The review highlights the key movements in financial performance across Indian industries. There is an improvement of liquidity and efficiency ratios. Profitability is strong, where governance is transparent, but ESG factors integration is still limited. Predicting financial distress needs both quantitative signs like numbers and qualitative signs like audit issues and leadership challenges. Finally, cross industry competitions show that sectors with clear sustainability and ethical practices perform better over a period of time.

 

The study focused on solvency, liquidity, profitability distress prediction and industry comparison. Solvency is often measured by using debt equity ratios, but few studies included macroeconomic impacts like interest rates or inflation. Strategic debt restructuring was also found to be important, especially for large-firms but it was not deeply explored. In the area of liquidity, most studies used current and quick ratios. However, these are not enough to reflect real time liquidity issues. Cash flow analysis and tools like ALM are more effective but rarely used. Financial distress was mainly predicted using the Altman Z score model. The final theme shows that cross industry comparison is still feeble in most research. It suggests that future research should focus on broader indicators, use modern tools and include ESG and sectoral benchmarking. By doing this, the quality and relevance of financial analysis can improve.

 

REFERENCES:

1.      Goel P. A study on Impact of Ethical Business Practices on Corporate Performance and Reporting [dissertation]. Belgaum: Visvesvaraya Technological University; 2016. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/481365

2.      Sharma R. Financial Analysis of Public Sector Undertakings: A case study of Allahabad Bank [dissertation]. Bhopal: AISECT University; 2017. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/271861

3.      Srivastava A. Performance Analysis of Energy Sector in India: A Study of Pre and Post Disinvestment [dissertation]. Agra: Dayalbagh Educational Institute; 2016. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/230632

4.      Raghuvanshi N. Financial Appraisal of Tyre Industries: A comparative study of MRF Ltd and JK Tyre Industry Ltd [dissertation]. Bhopal: Barkatullah University; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/499848

5.      Singha SD. Corporate Financial Reporting in India: the changing perspective [dissertation]. Agra: Dayalbagh Educational Institute; 2002. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/204791

6.      Maheshkumar PV. Analysis of financial statement of selected cooperative dairies with respect to Surat district [dissertation]. Ahmedabad: Gujarat University; 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/577022

7.      Moorthy SV. A Study of solvency and profitability position with selected pharmaceutical companies limited in India [dissertation]. Coimbatore: Bharathiar University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/619829

8.      Gautam S. Impact of financial leverage with special reference to merger and acquisition in Indian Pharmaceutical Industry with respect to Delhi NCR region [dissertation]. Aligarh: Mangalayatan University; 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/634462

9.      Hemaprasanna S. Determinants of financial leverage: Evidence from corporate India [dissertation]. Coimbatore: Bharathiar University; 2016. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/233252

10.   Tiwari SC. Capital structure analysis of selected Automobile Two Wheeler Companies [dissertation]. Rajkot: Saurashtra University; 2013. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/33047

11.   Subherwal D. Financial Appraisal of Public Sector Undertaking in Madhya Pradesh: with special reference to Narmada Hydro Electric Power Development Corporation Limited [dissertation]. Bhopal: Barkatullah Vishwavidyalaya; 2019. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/347916

12.   Rajendran G. Financial management in NRB bearings company ltd a study [dissertation]. Tiruchirappalli: Bharathidasan University; 2016. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/112225

13.   Bais MK. Impact of capital structure on profitability of selected listed E-Commerce Companies in India [dissertation]. Jaipur: IIS (Deemed University); 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/628030

14.   Angra SK. Normative model for financial appraisal of commercial undertakings [dissertation]. Shimla: Himachal Pradesh University; 2000. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/121048

15.   Kalebar RU. Data Evolvement Analysis for complementing financial ratios: financial statement analysis of Indian Automobile Industry [dissertation]. Mysore: University of Mysore; 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/597207

16.   Shah TB. Financial Statement Analysis: A Comparative Study of Paper Industry in India [dissertation]. Surat: Veer Narmad South Gujarat University; 2019. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/320519

17.   Panda AK. Liquidity analysis in the corporate sector of eastern India [dissertation]. Bhubaneswar: Utkal University; 2000. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/119379

18.   Ahuja N. Asset Liability Management of Housing Finance Companies in India [dissertation]. Gurgaon: Amity University, Haryana; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/457465

19.   Mengal SG. Financial performance analysis of Non Government Organization (NGOs) working in Konkan region [dissertation]. Pune: Savitribai Phule Pune University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/632606

20.   Sharma M. A study of financial performance and operating efficiency analysis of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL) [dissertation]. Jodhpur: Jai Narain Vyas University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/547314

21.   Kaur T. A study on Financial Position and Performance analysis of Information Technology Companies [dissertation]. Mandi Gobindgarh: Desh Bhagat University; 2019. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/316506

22.   Umrethwala DH. A Comparative study on Financial Statement Analysis of selected Non-Banking Financial Companies [dissertation]. Anand: Sardar Patel University; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/569509

23.   Monoharan P. Profitability of Cement Industry in India; An Empirical study [dissertation]. Coimbatore: Bharathiar University; 2002. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/102275

24.   Mehata AB. A Comparative study on Financial Analysis of selected Textile companies in India [dissertation]. Vallabh Vidyanagar: Sardar Patel University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/509757

25.   Hammad MM. The Impact of Accounting Disclosure Inequality of Financial and Non-Financial Performance in Light of Electronic field study [dissertation]. Ahmedabad: Gujarat University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/508079

26.   Singh A. Impact of Mergers on Corporate Performance in India [dissertation]. Chandigarh: Punjab University; 2015. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/248785

27.   Kumar JU. Financial performance of select Aluminum companies in India [dissertation]. Coimbatore: Bharathiar University; 2016. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/231332

28.   Nimeshkumar TH. A study on financial performance of selected rubber companies in India [dissertation]. Ahmedabad: Gujarat University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/523918

29.   Srinivas M. A study on Financial Performance of NTPC [dissertation]. Hyderabad: Osmania University; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/492993

30.   Peppal S. An Empirical Analysis of Financially Distressed Indian Companies (With Ref. to Public Sector Manufacturing Companies) [dissertation]. Agra: Dayalbagh Educational Institute; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/493544

31.   Raval BR. Financial performance analysis of selected insurance companies in India with reference to Altman Z score model [dissertation]. Rajkot: Atmiya University; 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/599668

32.   Kiran J. The Leverage decision, Agency cost of Debt and financial distress: A case study of selected highly levered companies in India [dissertation]. Mysore: University of Mysore; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/612041

33.   Bapodara LR. A Competitive Study of Financial Performance of Selected Companies In India through Altman Z score model [dissertation]. Junagadh: Bhakta Kavi Narsinh Mehta University; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/568395

34.   Gupta A. Application of Neural network in Financial Statement Fraud Detection: A Case Study of Selected Indian Companies [dissertation]. Udaipur: Mohanlal Sukhadia University; 2017. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/219792

35.   Kapoor T. An Analysis of Financial Performance of Indian Railways [dissertation]. Lucknow: Dr. Shakuntala Mishra National University; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/620181

36.   Makkar A. Financial Viability and Distress Analysis of Indian Commercial Banks [dissertation]. Hisar: Guru Jambheshwar University of Science and Technology; 2014. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/88986

37.   Tiwari HN. Firm Characteristics and Capital Structure Decision: An Empirical study [dissertation]. New Delhi: University of Delhi; 2022. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/619693

38.   Jansirani S. An explorative analysis of financial management of small medium enterprises in Tamil Nadu with special reference to small medium enterprises in Chennai [dissertation]. Tiruchirappalli: Bharathidasan University; 2018. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/245221

39.   Agarwal S. Digital Financial Services and Financial Inclusion: A study of Varanasi district [dissertation]. Varanasi: Banaras Hindu University; 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/588837

40.   Rajwade SK. A study on financial performance analysis of public and private sector banks by using CAMEL’s rating approach [dissertation]. Allahabad: Sam Higginbottom Institute of Agriculture, Technology and Science; 2025. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/636556

41.   Desai D. Analysis of Financial Statements for Prediction of Financial Soundness of Banks [dissertation]. Udaipur: Pacific Academy of Higher Education and Research University; 2014. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/321120

42.   Maheshkumar PV. Analysis of financial statement of selected cooperative dairies with respect to Surat district [dissertation]. Ahmedabad: Gujarat University; 2024. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/577022

43.   Rajendrabhai KM. A Study on Audit Perceptions of Auditors and Users of Financial Statement Indicators [dissertation]. Ahmedabad: Gujarat University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/523921

44.   Patil KK. Analysis of Interpretation of Financial Statements of Pharmaceutical Companies in India: A Case study of Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Limited [dissertation]. Nashik: Institute of Management Research and Technology, M.V.P. Campus; 2015. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/137895

45.   Drangay MD. Financial Statement Analysis of Select Paint Companies in India [dissertation]. Chidambaram: Annamalai University; 2018. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/622396

46.   Sangappa AH. Financial Performance of Paint Industries in India [dissertation]. Nanded: Swami Ramanand Teerth Marathwada University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/509178

47.   Chattopadhyay GC. Financial performance appraisal of Eastern Coalfields Limited [dissertation]. Burdwan: University of Burdwan; 2014. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/21899

48.   Shaw BK. An analysis of Financial Performance of select Life Insurance Companies in India during post reform period [dissertation]. Purulia: Sidhu Kanho Birsha University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/573847

49.   Zadeh TH. Analysis of Financial Statements for Investment Decisions [dissertation]. Thiruvananthapuram: Kerala University; 2017. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/565066

50.   Khushboo. Comparative Evaluation of Earnings Management Strategies: A study of select Indian companies [dissertation]. Chandigarh: Punjab University; 2023. Available from: https://hdl.handle.net/10603/556816

 

 

 

Received on 27.04.2026      Revised on 26.05.2026

Accepted on 23.06.2026      Published on 20.07.2026

Available online from July 30, 2026

Asian Journal of Management. 2026;17(3):286-294.

DOI: 10.52711/2321-5763.2026.00043

©AandV Publications All right reserved

 

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Creative Commons License.